Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe (2024)

Home » Recipes » Main Dishes » Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe

posted by Amy Johnsonon January 24, 2019 32 comments »

This post may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Jump to Recipe

This Sautéed Mushrooms with Cheesy Polenta Recipe, flavorful mushrooms sautéd in herbs and a balsamic vinegar sauce, and served with creamy polenta with melted gouda cheese, is the perfect savory appetizer or main dish.

Over the years there are those meals that stand out as favorites. The ones you want to rush home to recreate right away. But sometimes life gets in the way, we get distracted and find ourselves years later still thinking about something like, say, mushrooms and creamy polenta.

Several years ago during a work trip to Napa, we were treated to a delightful dinner at Michael Chiarello’s famed Botega restaurant. Certainly not an everyday (or every year, for that matter) dining experience for me. A variety of appetizers were ordered for our group, but one stood out from the rest: Polenta Under Glass. I knew after the first bite of the rich balsamic mushroom sauce and cheesy polenta that evening that I wanted to come home and re-create that savory goodness as soon as possible.

Years went by as I delayed recreating the memorable dish. As you may know, stuff happens. We put off and postpone and shelve those things that add flavor to our lives, even something as simple as mushrooms and polenta. I don’t know why. Life is too short to leave anything on the back burner for too long.

Even though it took me a while to get around to recreating the wonderful flavor combination, it was definitely worth the (unnecessary) wait. Sautéed Mushrooms with Cheesy Polenta Recipe, a savory appetizer or main dish of flavorful mushrooms sautéd in herbs and a rich balsamic vinegar sauce, spooned over creamy polenta with melted gouda cheese, is a dish you shouldn’t wait to make. It’s obsession worthy, I promise. And such a simple dish to make. I don’t know why I waited so long. Make sure you don’t delay like I did. Try it soon!

Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe

Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe (3)

Sautéed Mushrooms with Cheesy Polenta Recipe

Yield: 4-6

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 25 minutes

Total Time: 40 minutes

Asavory appetizer or main dish of flavorful mushrooms sautéd in herbs and a rich balsamic vinegar sauce, spooned over creamy polenta with melted gouda cheese.

Ingredients

For mushrooms:

  • 4 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 1/2 pounds mushrooms, sliced (Baby Bella or mixture)
  • 3/4 teaspoon dried thyme
  • 3/4 teaspoon dried oregano
  • 3/4 teaspoon black pepper
  • 6 garlic cloves, minced/grated
  • 3 tablespoons balsamic vinegar
  • 3/4 cup chicken broth
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • salt to taste

For polenta:

  • 2 1/2 cups milk
  • 2 1/4 cups chicken broth
  • 1 1/2 cups instant polenta
  • 8 ounces gouda* cheese, shredded
  • salt to taste

Instructions

  1. For mushrooms: Warm a large skillet over medium-high heat. Add oil. When oil ripples, add mushrooms; and cook stirring occasionally for 7 minutes. Stir in thyme, oregano, pepper and garlic; continue to cook, stirring, for 1 minute. Stir in balsamic vinegar, scraping up any brown bits from bottom of pan, stirring constantly about 30 seconds. Stir in chicken broth, reduce to low. Stir in butter. Salt to taste. Keep warm.**
  2. For polenta: In a saucepan, bring 2 1/2 cups milk and 2 1/4 cups chicken broth to a boil. Reduce heat to medium; gradually stir in polenta; cook, stirring constantly until mixture thickens, about 3 minutes. Add more liquid (broth, milk or water) as needed to achieve desired consistency. Remove from heat. Add shredded cheese; stir to combine until smooth. Salt to taste. Serve polenta warm topped with mushrooms.

Notes

*Other cheeses may be substituted. A few recommendations: Gouda, Gruyère, Havarti, Fontina, Cheddar

**For more sauce/gravy, increase chicken broth a tad—about 1/4 cup at a time to desired consistency.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Facebook

Originally published October 24, 2016.

Related Posts:

Chicken Breasts with Mushroom Sauce Recipe
Glazed Baby Back Ribs Recipe
Prime Rib Roast Recipe

Main Dishes

published on January 24, 2019

32 commentsLeave a comment »

« Previous PostCoconut Milk Baked Chicken Recipe

Next Post »Oatmeal Lemon Blueberry Bars

Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe (8)

ABOUT AMY

What began as a place for me to explore and share about my random hobbies and interests, has morphed into mostly sharing recipes — essentially a living, breathing, growing cookbook that is my absolute pleasure to share with you. The recipes here are simple, easy to prepare and nourishing for body and soul. Read more...

Get the Latest!

subscribe now and get new posts delivered via email:

Leave a Reply

32 comments on “Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe”

  1. Susie MandelReply

    Work trip to Napa–one of my favorite places in all the earth. 🙂 Michael Chiarello’s restaurant must have been awesome!!

  2. TraciReply

    Looks delicious, but I have a question. The picture shows the mushrooms glistening, but dry. In your recipe, the mushrooms require 3/4 cup of chicken froth, which should make it very saucy. Do you drain any excess liquid, or do you simmer till all the liquid has evaporated?

    • Amy Johnson

      It is saucy. The picture shows a serving with mushrooms that were added using a slotted spoon. More sauce is definitely better!

    • Ros Tangorra

      Thank you…just made mushrooms and was wondering why I had so much liquid

  3. JulieReply

    I can’t believe I stumbled upon this! I had the same dish at the same restaurant 6 years too and knew that I would have to have it again. I’m going to make it tomorrow! Thanks Amy. It really was an unbelievable dish.

    • Amy Johnson

      I hope you enjoy it, Julie!

  4. JanReply

    Hi. Made this last night for dinner. This is the best. Thank you for sharing

    • Amy Johnson

      Happy to hear that you enjoyed it, Jan!

  5. KellyReply

    Instead of regular milk, could I use an alternative? Almond or coconut milk perhaps?

  6. LouiseReply

    This recipe is delicious but the proportions seem way off. This makes about twice as much polenta as you need, even for 1.5 lbs of mushrooms. I ended up buying more mushrooms and reheating the leftover polenta, adding enough broth to restore it to its original consistency. Next time I will make half the amount of polenta and we will probably still have some left.

  7. SabrinaReply

    wow, have had most of these separately as a side dish, but never combined as a side dish or otherwise, thank you for this recipe

  8. SandraReply

    The restaurant is actually spelled Bottega. Here’s the actual recipe, if you want it:http://static.contentres.com/media/documents/8c58d3d7-0c32-4f57-8d2a-cdc14f6fced1.pdf

  9. LeaReply

    Thank you many times over for a delicious recipe for polenta! I’ve come back to this more times than I can count, it’s definately a requested recipe by friends and family at this point. I’m making it tomorrow in an enormous amount for my niece’s high school graduate party, her request! Delicious and the extra sauce is a bonus. 😁

  10. KatyReply

    A friend gifted me with some mushrooms and tried this recipe. I loved the results. Thanks Amy for sharing.

  11. LauraReply

    Thanks for the recipe. I enjoyed the mushrooms but found that they exuded so much liquid that I did not need the chicken broth. Other than that, they were great! I used another recipe for the polenta.

Leave a comment »

Sauteed Mushroom with Cheesy Polenta Recipe (2024)

FAQs

Should polenta be soaked before cooking? ›

If you feel like it is getting too thick earlier than that, simply whisk in more liquid and keep cooking. One way to reduce the cooking time is to soak your polenta overnight in water and drain it before cooking.

What do you eat with creamy polenta? ›

Cooked veggies are the perfect way to add hearty texture, richness, and flavor to creamy polenta. Try pairing it with roasted broccoli, Brussels sprouts, tomatoes, butternut squash, or cauliflower, with grilled mixed vegetables or zucchini, or with sautéed mushrooms.

How do you make polenta not gritty? ›

A ratio of five parts liquid to one part cornmeal by volume produces polenta that's fully hydrated and cooked through, without any little raw, gritty bits. An optional presoaking step helps hydrate the cornmeal and cuts down on actual cooking time.

Why is my polenta not creamy? ›

**Liquid Ratio:** The ratio of liquid (water or stock) to cornmeal is crucial. Using too little liquid can result in a thicker, drier polenta. Adding more liquid and stirring regularly can help achieve a creamier consistency.

How do you keep polenta creamy? ›

Slowly pour the cornmeal into the pot, maintaining a boil and continuing to stir. This is basically prevents lumps and clumping. Once all the cornmeal has been added, reduce the heat to a low simmer and stir frequently until polenta gets creamy.

What do Italians eat with polenta? ›

Polenta can be served with various toppings, like tomato meat sauce or a “white” sauce of sausage and mushrooms. In Abruzzo, especially in the province of Aquila during Lent, polenta is served with snail sauce or cooked in milk and served seasoned with oil, garlic and chili peppers.

Are grits and polenta the same? ›

Yes, both grits and polenta are made from ground corn, but the main difference here is what type of corn. Polenta, as you can probably guess from the color, is made from yellow corn, while grits are normally made from white corn (or hominy).

What is good to mix with polenta? ›

Once you try some of these polenta recipes, I think you'll agree that polenta is simple, elegant and delicious! Spoon steamed or cooked veggies over hot polenta. Add cheese, herbs or other favorite seasonings. Top polenta with your favorite pasta sauce.

How do you make polenta taste better? ›

The Mix-Ins. In my opinion, the only things that should be added besides seasoning and milk are butter and Parmesan or Pecorino Romano cheese. Personally, I think Pecorino Romano is the better choice here. It has more of a sharp funk than Parmesan, plus a much creamier texture that melts more readily into warm polenta.

What are the black specks in polenta? ›

It's normal to have black specks in your polenta. During processing, the corn kernel germ gets ground into the cornmeal. It's typically a darker colour, so it leaves behind black flakes. Why is my polenta gummy?

How do you make Martha Stewart polenta? ›

In a large, deep saucepan, bring 5 cups of water to a boil. While whisking constantly, add polenta in a slow, steady stream. Reduce heat to medium, cook until thickened, stirring occasionally with a wooden spoon, about 15 minutes. Remove pan from heat and stir in cheese, heavy cream, and butter.

Do you have to stir polenta constantly? ›

It definitely does not need to be stirred continuously. Fairly frequently, yes, to avoid burning on the bottom, but not constantly. Cooking for more or less time has more impact on texture than flavor. Cooked briefly, you get more of a grain-like cream of wheat texture.

Why do Italians love polenta? ›

Today, polenta is believed to be Italy's most popular staple food after pasta and pizza. At its core it remains a humble communal dish, but during the WWII years was eaten mainly out of necessity.

Does tubed polenta go bad? ›

For the best experience, we always recommend consuming Polenta before the “best by” date. Though safe to consume beyond that date, the product quality may deteriorate. Please use your best judgment and do not eat if the product has visible mold or an off smell.

How do you prepare ready to eat polenta? ›

Cube the precooked polenta, and season it to your liking. That might mean just salt and pepper, or it could include dried oregano, garlic powder, and red pepper flakes. You can either pan-fry or bake the polenta cubes until they are crispy. Chill the polenta croutons, and then use them to top a salad.

Why does my polenta stick to the pan? ›

If your skillet or griddle is not greased well and hot enough, the polenta, or grits, or cornmeal mush slices will stick to the pan.

Why is my polenta gummy? ›

You want coarse, stone-ground yellow corn to make the most delicious polenta. Instant polenta is parboiled, and while it does cook in less time than it takes to boil water, the trade-off is that the final product is often a gummy, gloopy mess. So, always avoid it. For the real deal, the extra time is worth it.

What's the best way to eat polenta? ›

Polenta pairs extremely well with stews, braised meats, saucy bean dishes, and roasted vegetables. It's the perfect cozy companion to all of your warm winter meals. Try it with our Chicken Cacciatore, or Slow Cooker Beef Stew!

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Allyn Kozey

Last Updated:

Views: 5360

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Allyn Kozey

Birthday: 1993-12-21

Address: Suite 454 40343 Larson Union, Port Melia, TX 16164

Phone: +2456904400762

Job: Investor Administrator

Hobby: Sketching, Puzzles, Pet, Mountaineering, Skydiving, Dowsing, Sports

Introduction: My name is Allyn Kozey, I am a outstanding, colorful, adventurous, encouraging, zealous, tender, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.