carrot cake recipe – use real butter (2025)

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (1) Recipe: carrot cake

The other morning as I hauled myself to the garage, I spied this lovely dawn from our driveway:


carrot cake recipe – use real butter (2)

…because you have to get up early if you want to catch the powder on the big mountains. Beaver Creek is the fanciest up-scale ski resort I have ever had the privilege of sullying with my middle class presence.


w00t!

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (3)


first lift up – look at these lovely bumps

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (4)

I’m not so much a ski bunny, more like a

ski

tele whore. The only reason we could ever consider skiing at such a posh resort (they have their own Ritz-Carlton on the slopes!?) is because we have Colorado Passes. Instead of $92 for a lift ticket, we paid $380 several months ago for unlimited access to Breckenridge, Arapahoe Basin, Keystone, and 10 days between Vail and Beaver Creek. Waugh, bon marché! Living in Colorado rocks. While I didn’t score any of those fresh-out-of-the-oven chocolate chip cookies served by the Beaver Creek chefs (we didn’t hang out at the village much), my eyeballs enjoyed plenty of eye candy. The terrain is by far the loveliest I’ve ever seen for a ski hill.


prettiest combat skiing ever

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (5)

the views are nothing to sniff at either

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (6)

snow-capped peaks make me salivate

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (7)

It was a bluebird day and it got downright hot (in the 30s) in my opinion. The few inches of powder were tracked up quickly, but it was great fun. Jeremy had himself the most indulgent $12 burger for lunch (he says it was good, but $12?!?!) and by mid-afternoon my legs were begging for the 2 hour drive home.

I paid the price for skiing above my station. I could barely walk around the house yesterday because I was so wiped out. But today I felt like my old self. Got my 2 hours of cardio and then decided it was time to make a cake!

rabbit food
I love carrots, but I hate baby carrots. When baby carrots first hit the market we thought, “What a great thing to bring on hikes or backpacking.” Well, I think they taste like ass. I mean, they’re whittled down from reject carrots and they have *no flavor*. I quickly reverted back to loose or bunch organic carrots which are sweet and delicious and good for you.


shredding carrots

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (8)

Whenever I trim, peel, slice, or chop fruits and vegetables, Kaweah likes to sit by the compost bucket. She could easily plunge her schnoz into the bucket while we aren’t home, but she never does. She’s a good girl. However, if I chuck bits or peels into the bucket while she’s sitting there, she gets closer and closer until finally her little brain can’t help but instruct her chops to reach out and try to catch something as it flies past. Carrots rank high on her list of all-time favorites. Rather than shred my fingers into the carrots, I just give the pooch the butt ends and she loves it.


that’s a girl

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (9)

I hadn’t made a carrot cake in about a year. It’s really simple to make and you get this dense, moist, full-of-goodies textured cake. It can be baked in a pan and frosted in said pan or layered up in a less modest presentation. I chose a small 6-inch, 4-layer version.


butter the pans

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (10)

mix the cake ingredients

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (11)

I found the recipe from a bed and breakfast website and added walnuts. The cake is chocked full of carrots, pineapple, walnuts, and wonderful spices. Can’t say I have tested any other recipe after I tried this one a few years ago. It’s a keeper, as is the cream cheese frosting.


cooling

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (12)

beating the sugar into the frosting

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (13)

like silk

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (14)

The reason it’s important to cool the cakes completely is because slicing a hot cake is a recipe for a lot of swearing. They tend to rip up and crumb when they are still steaming, and this cake does plenty of that when it is cooled. I lop off the dome tops (save for snacking) and then slice four layers of equal thickness. Set a base piece on the bottom, then layer with icing and top off with another base piece, but inverted.


spreading the frosting between layers

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (15)

Since the cake is crumb-y, I find it essential to spread a crumb coat on the sides before applying the real frosting layer. For presentation purposes, it’s unsightly to have a dark colored cake crumb suspended in a lovely sea of creamy white frosting. That’s just me though. The final cake is a heavy one, so don’t be fooled by the petite size.


just a small slice will do

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (16)

oh my

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (17)

a slightly fancier iteration of the same cake

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (18)

Update [January 16, 2024]: Last year, on a whim, I tested a small batch of chocolate cream cheese frosting with carrot cake scraps and determined that this needed to be a thing. It is *such* a good thing. Usually I will use both vanilla and chocolate cream cheese frostings for some visual and flavor contrast. It works quite well.


on a single layer square cake

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (19)

one layer of chocolate cream cheese frosting with swirls of vanilla and chocolate on top (with sprinkles)

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (20)

back to the four-layer 6-inch round

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (21)

this was for jeremy’s birthday

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (22)

cross-section view

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (23)


Carrot Cake
[print recipe]
adapted from Ridge View Bed and Breakfast, Virginia by Eleanor Damico

carrot cake
1 1/2 cups flour
1 cup sugar
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp ground cinnamon
1/2 tsp ground cloves
1 tsp allspice
2/3 cup cooking oil
2 eggs
1 cup finely shredded raw carrot
1/2 cup crushed pineapple (with syrup)
1 tsp vanilla extract
1/2 walnuts, chopped

cream cheese frosting
8 oz. cream cheese, room temperature
2 oz. unsalted butter, room temperature
2 tsps vanilla extract
pinch salt
1 lb. confectioner’s sugar

chocolate cream cheese frosting (optional – make this instead of or in addition to the cream cheese frosting)
modified from Chocolate Covered Katie
8 oz. cream cheese, room temperature
2 oz. unsalted butter, room temperature
2 oz. dark chocolate (70% cocoa or more), melted and cooled (but not solid)
1/2 cup cocoa powder (I used Dutch-processed)
1 1/2 tsps vanilla extract
1/2 tsp almond extract (optional, but I love it)
pinch salt
1 1/2 – 3 cups confectioner’s sugar (I used 200 grams or just under 1 cup)

Cake: Stir dry ingredients together in a large bowl. Add remaining cake ingredients and mix until moistened. Pour batter into greased and lightly floured baking pan. For a 9x9x2 inch baking pan, bake at 350°F for about 35 minutes or until toothpick comes out clean or with moist crumbs. I baked in 2 6-inch round pans at 375°F for 45 minutes (at elevation). Remove cakes from oven and when slightly cooled, invert onto cooling rack out of pan and let cool completely.

Cream cheese frosting: Cream the butter and cream cheese together until completely blended. Add vanilla and salt. Blend. Gradually beat in confectioner’s sugar to desired consistency. Note: I usually make this into a layer cake, so I typically make 1.5 times the amount of frosting. If there is any leftover, the frosting works beautifully on cinnamon buns.

Chocolate cream cheese frosting: Cream the butter and cream cheese together. Stir in the melted chocolate until blended. Mix in the cocoa powder, vanilla, almond extract (if using), and salt. Slowly beat in the confectioner’s sugar until you reach the desired sweetness or consistency. Note: if you like your frosting really sweet and it becomes too stiff, loosen it by beating in a little milk (or plant-based milk).

February 28th, 2008: 7:58 pm
filed under baking, cake, dessert, recipes, sweet, vegetables

carrot cake recipe – use real butter (2025)

FAQs

Can I use butter instead of oil in my carrot cake? ›

Recipe Variations

The carrot cake gets its flavor from the other ingredients — like the carrots and spices. That said, if you prefer to use butter instead of oil, you can substitute with an equal amount of melted butter in this recipe.

Can you use real butter for cakes? ›

Butter is the favoured fat to use in cakes and bakes and we use unsalted butter for all of our cakes in the bakeries. It is made from churned cream, a process that separates the butterfat from the buttermilk. It is typically made from cow's milk and is yellow in colour.

Can you use real butter in cake mix? ›

Butter can give a great flavour to cakes and coats the proteins and starches during the mixing step and results in a more delicate crumb. It also impacts richness and flavour.

Why is there no butter in carrot cake? ›

What makes a moist Carrot Cake? Using vegetable oil instead of butter keeps the cake nice and moist, and adding milk also lends itself to a very soft cake. I recommend measuring all the ingredients to ensure you don't accidentally add too much flour.

What happens if I use butter instead of oil in cake? ›

Most cake mixes call for oil, but butter will bring in amazing flavor. To substitute butter for oil in baking just melt the butter, measure it, let it cool, and add it as you would the oil. Compared to oil, butter will create a cake with a firmer, cakeier texture.

What is a substitute for vegetable oil in carrot cake? ›

Use an equal amount of applesauce as the amount of oil or butter called for in the recipe. Yogurt: Yogurt is another popular substitute for oil or butter, as it adds moisture and richness to the cake. Use an equal amount of yogurt as the amount of oil or butter called for in the reci.

Do bakeries use real butter? ›

You're more likely to find butter flavor in store bought pastries than real butter. You need to check the labels to see what's in them. You will find butter and lard in bakery pastries, depending on the bakery and what kind of treats it bakes.

Which butter is best for cakes? ›

The best butter for your baked goods depends on what type of recipe you're whipping up. Unsalted, American-style butter works well in goods like cookies, pound cakes and pancakes that require the high-fat content of conventional butter and more flexibility with salt and flavor content.

Which butter should not be used for baking? ›

Baking recipes typically call for unsalted butter because the amount of salt in salted butter varies depending on the brand – there is no “industry standard.” For example, if you use one brand of salted butter in a recipe, and we use another, our baked goods could end up tasting very different from one other.

What happens if you use melted butter instead of softened butter? ›

Melted butter will make your cookies delightfully dense on the inside and crisp on the edges. This is because cookie dough with melted butter will give you extra moisture and spread out more during baking, giving you a softer inside and with thinner, crisper edges.

Is box cake better with oil or butter? ›

The directions on the back of the box will tell you to add vegetable oil; for a denser crumb and bigger flavor, swap in unsalted butter.

Why is butter not used in cake baking? ›

The water that's present in butter strengthens the gluten in a cake's flour, resulting in a crumb that's more dense and not quite as tender as a cake made with oil.

Which is better for carrot cake, oil or butter? ›

When preparing cakes without super strong flavors such as vanilla cake and white cake, I prefer to use butter as the fat. Butter also gives them flavor. But for cakes like chocolate cake and carrot cake that have flavor from other ingredients, I find flavorless oil is the best choice.

Why is my carrot cake dense and heavy? ›

If there is too much oil, then the cake will be dense and heavy and air bubbles will not be able to sustain themselves in the batter.

Why is my carrot cake too moist? ›

If you add too many mix-ins, you can dull the spicy flavor of the cinnamon and the nutmeg, or if you add wet ingredients like pineapple, your cake will come out too soggy and fall apart.

Does butter or vegetable oil make a cake more moist? ›

Replacing butter with vegetable oil in your cake recipes typically yields moist results. Unlike butter, vegetable oil remains liquid at room temperature, ensuring your cake maintains a soft texture, whether served fresh or straight from the refrigerator.

What can I substitute for oil in cake? ›

  • Melted Butter.
  • Avocado.
  • Unsweetened Applesauce.
  • Greek Yogurt.
  • Shortening.
  • Coconut Oil.
  • Bacon Grease.
  • Nut Butters.
Nov 3, 2023

Why is my carrot cake so greasy? ›

According to Bon Appétit, this phenomenon is due to the fact that the batter used in this type of baked good is oil-based rather than butter-based.

What is the best oil for baking cakes? ›

Canola oil is, without doubt, one of the best types of oil for baking. It's preferred in many recipes since it has the most neutral flavor compared to other types of oil. It also tends to be lighter in flavour, so it will not negatively affect the baked product's flavor and texture.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 6116

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.